When good cards go bad, a personal testimonial

By Joe Farace

Memory cards fail for lots of reasons. Sometimes it’s the card’s fault, other times the camera's and often it’s (heaven forbid) the user who creates the problem. Laying blame is irrelevant when you just want your files back.

When my 4GB Lexar Professional CompactFlash card failed, I reached for PhotoRescue software, which will usually recover images from reformatted cards. But it couldn’t solve this particular problem. Next I tried ProSoft Picture Rescue, but it wouldn’t work on this card either. The Image Rescue software included on every Lexar Professional CF card can recover lost or deleted JPEG, TIFF and RAW files from erased, reformatted, or corrupted memory cards, but after recovering just a few files, it stalled.

Since Lexar Professional cards have a lifetime warranty, I contacted Customer Support, FedEx'd my card off to Fremont, Calif., and waited with my fingers crossed. A week later (rescue time varies depending on their work load), I received a stack of CDs with 500 recovered images and a replacement 4GB CompactFlash card. My wife, Mary, is considering a return to professional photography. When she saw this story play out, it helped make up her mind about what kind of memory cards she would use to shoot weddings.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Comments (1)

John Greer:

Comment on: When good cards go bad, a personal testimonial
By Joe Farace (5/1/06).
We have found that Lexar PhotoRescue works differently at different times and on different platforms. Many times we have been unable to get recovery on an OS-X console or a Win-XP console, but had no problem on a Win-XP laptop. Results are consistent and reproducible, without explanation. Result: Try different machines before you give up.


This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on May 1, 2006 12:01 AM.

The previous post in this blog was Digital Album submission at International Print Competition 2006.

The next post in this blog is The CompactFlash card speedway.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 5.2.7